US Bank Directory
Banks in New Buffalo, MI
2 FDIC-insured banks operate 2 offices in New Buffalo, Michigan, and 2 credit unions have 2 offices.
Source: FDIC BankFind, data as of September 5, 2026; NCUA call report as of March 31, 2026; hours checked October 10, 2026.
Bank branch map: New Buffalo
Banks sit at the coordinates in their FDIC record; credit union offices at their NCUA address, located with the U.S. Census Bureau Geocoder. Point at a marker for today's hours, tap it for the address, directions and the bank's site.
Short answer: 4 banks and credit unions operate 4 locations in New Buffalo, according to the FDIC and the NCUA. 4 of them have coordinates on record and are on the map. 2 publish opening hours.
Branches: FDIC, NCUA. Streets: loading.
4 locations on the map
Tap a cluster to zoom in
Positions are the regulators' own coordinates, or the Census Geocoder's point for the address, and can sit a few hundred feet from the door. Streets, buildings and parks come from OpenStreetMap through OpenFreeMap, with every street named as you zoom in; if that map cannot load, a simpler map drawn from the Census Bureau's TIGER/Line files takes its place. ATMs will follow with the Overture Maps import.
All banks and credit unions in New Buffalo
Sorted by number of local branches. Each branch shows where its hours and phone number come from.
Short answer: Fifth Third Bank and Horizon Bank have the most locations in New Buffalo, with 1 each. 2 banks have a single office in the city. Open any bank to see each address, today's hours where the bank publishes them and the phone number.
Everwise Credit Union Credit union · 1
Everwise Credit Union has 1 office in New Buffalo, 4 across Michigan. It is based in South Bend, IN and $5.70 billion in assets on March 31, 2026, according to its NCUA call report. It opens on Saturday.
Who can join: see the credit union's site.
-
New Buffalo 6645 N Whittaker St, 49117
All hours
Mon to Thu 9 am to 4:30 pm; Fri 9 am to 5 pm; Sat 9 am to 12 pm; Sun not published
Hours: NCUA, March 31, 2026
Fifth Third Bank Bank · 1
Fifth Third Bank has 1 branch in New Buffalo, 308 across Michigan and 1,508 nationwide. FDIC records list its main office in Cincinnati, OH and show it operating since 1865. With $299.18 billion in total assets on June 30, 2026, it ranks No. 14 of 4,232 U.S. banks by total assets. The New Buffalo Branch at 1 W Buffalo St dates to 1946 in FDIC branch records. It opens on Saturday.
-
New Buffalo Branch1 W Buffalo St, 49117
All hours
Mon closed; Tue to Fri 9 am to 5 pm; Sat 9 am to 12 pm; Sun closed
Hours: Fifth Third Bank branch locator (All The Places), checked Oct 10, 2026
Horizon Bank Bank · 1
Horizon Bank has 1 branch in New Buffalo, 29 across Michigan and 79 nationwide. FDIC records list its main office in Michigan City, IN and show it operating since 1873. With $6.55 billion in total assets on June 30, 2026, it ranks No. 237 of 4,232 U.S. banks by total assets. The Alliance Bking Branch at 500 W Buffalo St dates to 1991 in FDIC branch records. It does not publish hours in the sources this page uses; check its site before you go.
-
Alliance Bking Branch500 W Buffalo St, 49117
United Credit Union Credit union · 1
United Credit Union has 1 office in New Buffalo, 17 across Michigan. It is based in St Joseph, MI and $4.40 billion in assets on March 31, 2026, according to its NCUA call report. It does not publish hours in the sources this page uses; check its site before you go.
Who can join: see the credit union's site.
-
New Buffalo Loan Office207 N Whittaker St Ste B, 49117
Join a credit union in New Buffalo
2 credit unions have 2 offices here: Everwise Credit Union and United Credit Union. Each office is listed above with the phone and the hours it filed with the NCUA (call report as of March 31, 2026). Who can join each one is on its own site; the credit unions in New Buffalo page has every office in the state's directory.
Banking in New Buffalo: the local picture
Short answer: 2 banks run 2 branches in New Buffalo according to the FDIC. A population estimate for this place is not available from the Census Bureau, so branches per resident are not shown.
Of the 2 banks, 0 have their main office in New Buffalo and 2 out of state, according to the FDIC.
The bank with the longest record here is Fifth Third Bank, operating since 1865 according to the FDIC. In FDIC branch records, the longest-running branch is Fifth Third Bank's office at 1 W Buffalo St, dating to 1946; the newest is Horizon Bank's at 500 W Buffalo St, from 1991.
2 credit unions have 2 offices in New Buffalo, according to the NCUA. Who can join each one is on the credit unions page.
Of the 2 locations with published hours. 2 open on Saturday. 2 locations have no published hours in these sources.
Banks and credit unions open on Saturday in New Buffalo
Short answer: 2 of the 2 New Buffalo locations with published hours open on Saturday, run by 2 institutions.
- Fifth Third Bank: 1 of 1 branch (1 W Buffalo St: Saturday 9 am to 12 pm)
- Everwise Credit Union: 1 of 1 office (45 N Whittaker St: Saturday 9 am to 12 pm)
Credit union hours are the text each credit union filed with the NCUA, call report as of March 31, 2026; a day the filing does not mention is shown as not published, never as closed. Bank branches show hours only where the bank publishes them in a source this page uses; 2 of the 4 locations here have no published hours yet. The source and date sit under each office. Banks and credit unions often close on Federal Reserve holidays; call ahead.
Chase, Bank of America and other national banks
Which big national banks have branches in New Buffalo, and where the nearest one is if they do not.
Short answer: In New Buffalo: Fifth Third Bank (1). No branches in New Buffalo: Chase (nearest in Stevensville, 19 mi), Wells Fargo (nearest in Birmingham, 189 mi), Bank of America (nearest in Grandville, 90 mi), PNC Bank (nearest in Paw Paw, 53 mi), U.S. Bank, Truist, Huntington (nearest in Stevensville, 20 mi), Regions Bank, TD Bank, BMO.
| Bank | In New Buffalo | Nearest branch if none here |
|---|---|---|
| Fifth Third Bank | 1 branch | here |
| Chase | None | Stevensville, 19 miles away |
| Wells Fargo | None | Birmingham, 189 miles away |
| Bank of America | None | Grandville, 90 miles away |
| PNC Bank | None | Paw Paw, 53 miles away |
| U.S. Bank | None | none in Michigan |
| Truist | None | none in Michigan |
| Huntington | None | Stevensville, 20 miles away |
| Regions Bank | None | none in Michigan |
| TD Bank | None | none in Michigan |
| BMO | None | none in Michigan |
Branch counts from FDIC BankFind as of September 5, 2026. Distances are straight-line miles from the center of New Buffalo to the nearest branch in Michigan.
What your savings could earn
National benchmarks and the best published offers, from the Banrox Bank Rates tracker. Enter your own balance and rate to compare.
Short answer: At the national average savings rate of 0.38%, $10,000 kept in savings for a year earns about $38. The best published savings rate in the tracker, 3.75% at CIT Bank, earns about $375. The national average 12-month CD pays 1.71%.
| Offer | Bank | APY | Term | Minimum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Savings | CIT Bank | 3.75% | none | $5,000 |
| Savings | Barclays | 3.50% | none | $0 |
| Savings | Marcus by Goldman Sachs | 3.40% | none | $0 |
| CD | Synchrony Bank | 4.35% | 60 Months | $0 |
| CD | Marcus by Goldman Sachs | 4.35% | 24 Months | $500 |
| CD | American Express National Bank | 4.25% | 10 Months | $0 |
Rates are the banks' published APYs as tracked on the Banrox Bank Rates page, with the date next to each benchmark; they are not offers from Banrox and can change daily. Interest is before tax. The best offers are mostly online banks and are open to New Buffalo residents like anyone else.
Banks near New Buffalo
Nearby cities with at least two banks, by straight-line distance. Counts from FDIC BankFind.
Short answer: The closest towns with more choice are Stevensville (20 miles) and Saint Joseph (24 miles). Saint Joseph, 24 miles away, has the most banks nearby: 7.
| City | Distance | Banks | Branches |
|---|---|---|---|
| Banks in Stevensville, MI | 20 mi | 3 | 3 |
| Banks in Saint Joseph, MI | 24 mi | 7 | 12 |
| Banks in Niles, MI | 26 mi | 5 | 9 |
| Banks in Benton Harbor, MI | 26 mi | 4 | 5 |
| Banks in Edwardsburg, MI | 34 mi | 2 | 2 |
| Banks in Dowagiac, MI | 35 mi | 3 | 5 |
| Banks in Coloma, MI | 36 mi | 2 | 3 |
| Banks in South Haven, MI | 48 mi | 3 | 4 |
Bank branch openings and closings in New Buffalo
FDIC branch records, between September 5, 2025 and September 5, 2026.
Short answer: FDIC branch records show no bank branch openings in New Buffalo between September 5, 2025 and September 5, 2026. Closings and relocations are not tracked by the sources this page uses yet.
Largest banks in New Buffalo by total assets
Ranked by each bank's total assets on its FDIC balance sheet, which covers the whole bank, not only its New Buffalo offices.
Short answer: Fifth Third Bank is the largest bank with offices in New Buffalo, with $299.18 billion in total assets on June 30, 2026, No. 14 among U.S. banks by total assets. Horizon Bank is second with $6.55 billion. Local deposit shares will follow once the FDIC Summary of Deposits is imported.
| Bank | Total assets | Rank | Offices here | Main office |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fifth Third Bank | $299.18 billion | No. 14 | 1 | Cincinnati, OH |
| Horizon Bank | $6.55 billion | No. 237 | 1 | Michigan City, IN |
Total assets and ranks from FDIC BankFind as of June 30, 2026. Rank is among active banks that report total assets to the FDIC.
Banks in New Buffalo: FAQ
How many banks are in New Buffalo, MI?
New Buffalo has 2 banks with 2 branches and 2 credit unions with 2 offices, according to FDIC data as of September 5, 2026 and NCUA data as of March 31, 2026.
Which bank has the most branches in New Buffalo?
Fifth Third Bank, with 1. Horizon Bank has 1.
Is there a Fifth Third Bank in New Buffalo, MI?
Yes. FDIC data lists 1 Fifth Third Bank branch in New Buffalo as of September 5, 2026. The address and directions are under Fifth Third Bank above.
Is there a Horizon Bank in New Buffalo, MI?
Yes. FDIC data lists 1 Horizon Bank branch in New Buffalo as of September 5, 2026. The address and directions are under Horizon Bank above.
Is there a Chase in New Buffalo, MI?
No. FDIC data lists no Chase branch in New Buffalo as of September 5, 2026. The nearest is in Stevensville, about 19 miles away in a straight line.
Which banks in New Buffalo are open on Saturday?
Fifth Third Bank and Everwise Credit Union publish Saturday hours for one or more New Buffalo locations. The Saturday section above lists each one with its hours. 2 of the 4 locations here do not publish hours in the sources this page uses; call ahead.
What is the oldest bank in New Buffalo?
Fifth Third Bank has the longest record among banks with a branch here: the FDIC shows it operating since 1865.
Which credit unions can I join in New Buffalo?
Everwise Credit Union and United Credit Union have offices in New Buffalo. Check each credit union's membership rules before you apply.
Did any bank branches open or close in New Buffalo in the past year?
FDIC branch records show no branch openings between September 5, 2025 and September 5, 2026. Closings and relocations are not tracked by the sources this page uses yet.
Where can I find more banks near New Buffalo?
Nearby cities with more banks include Stevensville, Saint Joseph, Niles. Stevensville is 20 miles away with 3 banks.
How we build this page
Every figure above comes from one of these sources. Nothing is typed by hand, nothing is estimated.
| Data | Source | License | Updated | Data as of |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FDIC-insured banks: branches, main offices, total assets, dates established | FDIC BankFind Suite API | Public data (U.S. government) | Monthly import | Sep 5, 2026 |
| Credit union offices, phones and hours as filed with the NCUA, total assets | NCUA call report data | Public data (U.S. government) | Quarterly import | Mar 31, 2026 |
| Map coordinates of 2 credit union offices whose NCUA record has none, from the office address | U.S. Census Bureau Geocoder | Public data (U.S. government) | With each NCUA import | Oct 19, 2026 |
| Bank branch hours, phones and branch pages (1 of 2 branches: Fifth Third Bank) | The banks' own branch locators, collected by All The Places | CC0 (All The Places data); each bank's locator is the primary source | Weekly spider run, monthly refresh here | Oct 10, 2026 |
| Savings and CD rates, national averages | Banrox Bank Rates | Banrox, from the banks' own rate pages and FDIC national rates | Weekly | see each rate |
See your odds before you apply
Banrox shows how likely a card or loan is for your profile, from your own data, without a hard pull. Platform live; card in early access; no card issued.
Check your odds